The basic differences between popular and scholarly articles arise from the audience for which the periodical is written.
CRITERIA | Popular Magazines or Newspapers | Scholarly Journals |
---|---|---|
AUDIENCE | general public | scholars, students, professionals |
APPEARANCE | lots of color, advertising, illustrations, short articles | mostly text, black & white, graphs & charts, long articles with bibliographies & footnotes |
CONTENT | feature articles on timely topics; written for a general audience in a language that is easy to understand | researched and footnoted articles; written for a specialized audience in a vocabulary that is not easily understood by the average reader |
AUTHOR(ITY) | written by staff & freelance writers; checked by editors | authored by researchers, academics, specialists; peer-reviewed |
EXAMPLES | Time; Business Week; People | The Journal of American History; Advanced Optical Technologies; Journal of Applied Psychology |
Sometimes it is difficult to determine what is original and what is an interpretation or distillation of an original work. Here is a great summary from University of Maryland that compares the three types of sources:
Teaching and Learning Services. "Primary, Secondary and Tertiary Sources." University of Maryland Libraries.